NFL's New Rules: Is American Football Going Soft?

The NFL is Implementing New Rules This Season. But Are They Really Necessary?

By Jack Oceano, published Sep 01, 2006
Published Content: 727  Total Views: 1,125,173  Favorited By: 123 CPs
Rating: 3.4 of 5
Commissioner Paul Tagliabue and the powers that be in the NFL are implementing new rules this season.  What are they?  And more importantly, how will the affect the way the game is played in the National Football League?

One the NFL's new rules is that defenders can no longer hit quarterbacks below the knee in the pocket.  This is no doubt in response to Cincinnati Bengals QB Carson Palmer's injury in the playoffs against the Pittsburgh Steelers.  I hated seeing Carson Palmer go down, but this is NFL football, not some pickup game of touch football out on the schoolyard.  The defenders already can't go near the helmet of the quarterback, even accidentally.  Late hits are called all too frequently, often when the defender can't stop his momentum and accidentally grazes the QB on his way to the ground.  The offensive lineman attempt to drive defenders onto the turf.  Now that defender will be useless once the offensive line accomplishes that.  The league can't protect against every possible contingency, but it seems that is what the NFL is trying to do.  Plenty of great quarterbacks survived the NFL without this rule: Joe Montana, John Elway, Dan Marino, Joe Namath, the list goes on and on.  This is one rule that isn't needed in the NFL, one that shows the NFL is too soft when it comes to QBs.  Also, it seems the league will not distinguish between intentional and unintentional contact.  

NFL's New Rules: Is American Football Going Soft?

Is American Football going soft?

Credit: Jack Oceano

Copyright: Jack Oceano

Takeaways
  • The NFL is too soft when it comes to QBs.
  • I have never understood the league's obsession with eliminating touchdown and sack celebrations.
  • Another ridiculous rule change is that down-by-contact calls will now be reviewable.
Did You Know?
Colts QB Peyton Manning wears a large brace on his knee to prevent that knee from being hyperextended. A brace sounds like a good alternative to the NFL's new rule regarding hitting QBs below the knee in the pocket.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
 
 
The NFL is just trying to protect the product. Ask the players from yesteryear if they would have liked to have 99% of these newer rules. Most will say yes. What I can't stand the most are late flags - especially for pass interference. Throw the flag as soon as you see the infraction. Dr. Footballstein @ http://FootballPokerGame.com

Posted on 12/06/2007 at 1:12:00 PM

 
The "horse collar" rule is ridiculas enough without adding the jersey. One of my favorite plays this year was watching Pittsburg's DB get brought down by his flowing mane.

Posted on 11/23/2006 at 5:11:00 PM

 
All these rules are crazy I wanna see crazy T.D dances I wanna see off tha wall celebrations ....it adds 2 the Creativeness of the Game its like in order for thing to get better u have to get more creative wen you take the creativeness away....then its just blan and plain and not interesting

Posted on 09/07/2006 at 6:09:00 PM

 
QB's are sissies... and you're right on re: the celebrations.

Posted on 09/01/2006 at 9:09:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
 
Most Commented On