Heath Ledger's Prior Anxiety Problems and the Mental Strain of Method Acting

By Gregoriancant, published Jan 29, 2008
Published Content: 321  Total Views: 124,156  Favorited By: 29 CPs
Rating: 3.9 of 5
Perhaps we should damn that old Stanislavsky acting technique of Method Acting. It arguably provides a process in giving a better performance in movies for actors, but it also can get under both the actor's (and the viewer's) skin when playing an unpleasant role. Actors have to basically live with the role they're playing to the point of eventual madness. Some documented evidence from past actors seems to show what it can do to a person's psyche. In the case of the now late Heath Ledger--it could be an indirect casualty from the process. From all appearances in Ledger's most recent film roles, he was a true advocate of Method Acting, whether through his own personal approach or through disciplined training. And, based on recently cryptic comments he made when playing the role of The Joker in "The Dark Knight" (now, eerily, his last performance), playing a much, much more sadistic version of this character became too psychologically tough to digest.

This isn't to say that Method Acting doesn't have its place in the acting world. We've managed to get some of the greatest performances in the history of film thanks to Method Actors. James Dean, Marlon Brando and Robert DeNiro (just to name the three you think of first) have taken roles they've conceived and made them beyond believable and compelling. The famous Actor's Studio in NYC promotes the process thanks to the controversial Elia Kazan, Cheryl Crawford and Robert Lewis who started it in 1947. And then, of course, Lee Strasberg forwarded it even further when he took over in 1952. Many of Strasberg's students learned well how to get inside a role--sometimes very disturbing ones. But roles in those days were obviously not as cutting edge as they are now.

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
 
Perhaps a high price to pay for them but we all need to believe in somebody and occassionally somebody somewhere like a Heath ledger or a Pryor or a Gershwin or a Sinatra or a Presley gives us something to believe in.

Posted on 02/23/2008 at 2:02:06 PM

 
I thought Heath Ledger's performance as Ennis Del Mar in Brokeback Mountain was one of the greatest performaqnces I've ever seen. Perhaps even the greatest by any actor ever. He gives Brando, DeNiro, and Dean a run for their money in that performance and also in I'm Not There and Monster's Ball. You see how I'm saying gives in the present tense - I still can't believe he's dead and probably never will. Just so damned talented and so damned unfortunate. Jay Leno told a story on hearing that his friend Richard Pryor died where he repeated an anecdote from one of George Gershwin's close friends upon hearing of Gershwin's untimely death at the age of 37 back in 1937 in which the friend is quoted as saying "They tell me George is dead. Well, I don't have to believe it if I don't want to." I'm with you George's buddy. They tell me Heath is dead but I'll never believe them and that goes for Richard Pryor and Gershwin as well. Some people never really die. Perhaps a high price to pay but we al

Posted on 02/23/2008 at 2:02:10 PM

 
Perhaps some younger actors are more vulnerable to the emotional effects which can accompany some roles. More experienced and seasoned actors may be somewhat more protected...I don't know. When you mentioned DeNiro I was immediately reminded of his chilling performance in the remake of "Cape Fear". Very intense and frightening character. Thank you for treating this subject with respect.

Posted on 02/02/2008 at 11:02:10 AM

 
Great article! My wife and I thought much the same when we first heard the news and read some of his recent quotes about the difficulties of the Joker role. Because my wife is a drama teacher, she knows a lot about the different styles of acting and the kind of strains Heath Ledger must've put himself through while excelling in his various roles. Personally, I'm still very excited to see his role in the Batman movie, but I think it's very unfortunate, for him and the entire movie audience, that no one will see his excellent performances in any more roles. You asked the question of how much more we'll see this in actors, and I often wonder that about Christian Bale. In my opinion, Christian Bale is an incredibly excellent actor, of the same caliber or even higher than Heath Ledger, and he puts himself in demanding roles all of the time (e.g. American Psycho, The Prestige). I hope he doesn't wind up with the same fate.

Posted on 01/31/2008 at 1:01:39 PM

 
I don't know if I have anything too intelligent to say about your article, which was interesting. Only that it made me think of an interview I saw with Daniel Day Lewis on the Charlie Rose Show. The one thing that struck me about him, more than one thing, is that he is known for completely immersing himself in his roles, and he does so willingly. He even went on to describe, how when he was playing Hamlet on stage, the scene where Hamlet is talking to his father, that Mr.Lewis felt that he was actually talking to his own father. Also, that Mr. Lewis does not take on that many movie roles, and I wonder if it is because of his preparation techniques. I do not know much about acting, but I think, no, I know its not about pretending to be someone else, but actually becoming someone else. If that is method acting, then yes I can see how it can influence someone mental health.

Posted on 01/29/2008 at 4:01:46 PM

Type in Your Comments Below
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
Most Commented On