Find » Opinion/Editorial » Democracy, the Constitution and the...

Democracy, the Constitution and the Judeo-Christian Concept of Free Will

3 Top Reasons Why Gay Unions and Abortions Should Be Allowed

By Opher Ganel, published Jan 27, 2008
Published Content: 33  Total Views: 21,029  Favorited By: 28 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.7 of 5
Many religious communities fight against gay marriages and abortion rights. This fight runs contrary to three crucial concepts of our society and religious faith, and endangers our republic.

Top reason #3 why gay unions and abortions should be allowed

One of the pillars on which our republic stands is the constitutional separation of church and state. The framers of the constitution looked back through history and realized that when a state accepts one religion as the "right" religion, that is the beginning of its end.

When religion is allowed and sometimes even used by the state to force people's choices, democracy is lost. The framers did not say that religion is wrong. They did not say that atheism is the best way to go through life.

The framers did realize however that religious faith is a choice that each individual must be allowed to exercise for him or herself. This freedom is what they sought when they separated church and state.

To argue on religious grounds that the government should ban gay marriage while supporting marriage as a union of one man and one woman flies in the face of that separation of church and state. The government must either allow both, or else get out of the marriage business altogether. To argue based on faith that Roe v. Wade must be overturned is wrong for the same reason.

Top reason #2 why gay unions and abortions should be allowed

Democracy is a form of government that gains its legitimacy from the agreement of the governed. The citizens agree to give up some of their personal freedoms in return for the advantages offered by organized society.

These freedoms that are given up include a portion of property rights, in the form of taxation. Another limitation accepted as part of our social contract is that the strong are not allowed to take from the weak. A third is the limitation placed on free speech when that speech incites to violence or hatred.

Democracy, the Constitution and the Judeo-Christian Concept of Free Will

The Statue of Liberty, one of the most recognizable icons of the United States of America, symbolizes freedom from oppression and tyranny. Those who seek to have the government prevent others from committing sins would render this promise hollow.

Credit: Derek Jensen

Copyright: Wikimedia Commons (Public Domain)

Takeaways
  • Banning gay marriage or abortion rights for religious reasons flies in the face of the constitution.
  • A democratic government does not have the right to decide on gay marriage or abortion rights.
  • Wheh God Himself gives us free will, how can anyone try to forcefully prevent another from sinning?
Did You Know?
Judaism addresses the apparent clash of God's omniscience and free will by saying "all is known and permission is granted." God knows our hearts but grants us permission to choose. This is the basis for personal accountability for wrong-doing.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 11 of 11
 
 
Well-said, Opher! While I don't personally agree with abortion, I do believe each individual should have the right to make that personal decision. Ultimately, these choices are between the individuals and God...not the government.

Posted on 05/05/2008 at 8:05:55 AM

 
Great job on this. I believe these are personal, moral decisions, and our government is run by many people who are not fit to determine what is morally right or wrong.

Posted on 05/05/2008 at 4:05:46 AM

 
Well done Opher! I'd prefer if the government would stay out of much more of our lives than these two issues, lol. As to regards of these two issues. I think all our choices are between us and our God. Will the government be there to answer for me in my day of judgement? I don't think so. Then there's that little questionable word too. Choice?

Posted on 03/01/2008 at 5:03:46 PM

 
Very good article. You presented the argument- which I whole heartedly agree with- without throwing in your personal beliefs which takes a lot of skill. One thing that is funny to me is the ad with your article is a vote prolife one.

Posted on 02/29/2008 at 10:02:53 PM

 
Excellent article, very thought-provoking. As a Christian, I don't agree that gay marriage or abortion are acceptable, but I do recognize that we all have the right to choose what we believe.

Posted on 02/19/2008 at 4:02:29 AM

 
Well expressed and clear arguments. I support separation of church and state and I am a Christian. How's that? LOL.

Posted on 02/01/2008 at 11:02:07 PM

 
Here I am, Mike -- and Opher!! :>) This was an excellent article, Opher. Can I just ditto Mike's comment? I know I didn't choose my sexual preference, and I don't know of anyone else (gay, straight, bi, trans) who did either. I just don't have an issue on way or another about sexuality and marriage, but I do think the government needs to stay out of it. There are much bigger issues out there, in my opinion. As for abortion, I can't stand the thought. And that's a harder one for me in terms of should the government be involved. Again, good article!

Posted on 01/29/2008 at 12:01:32 PM

 
As I said at the end of the article, I do not take here a moral position on abortion. Personally, I'd have a huge moral dilemma if a woman asked me if she should or should not have one. Legally, as I understand it, life starts at the first post-birth breath. Is that the true point? Is it when a fetus becomes viable enough to survive outside the uterus? Is it even earlier as maintained by the pro-life groups? My point here is that this decision must be made by the woman in question. A truly faithful person would acknowledge that God has given the woman free will and will hold her accountable for her choices. God has not given any other person, court or government the right to force the woman to "choose" a particular way.

Posted on 01/28/2008 at 4:01:10 AM

 
This is really thought-provoking for me, and presented with excellence. Gays? I believe people are born gay, such as my younger cousin, he was playing with dolls all through childhoold. Anybody taking issue with this, to me, needs to have a heart-to-heart with The Creator. If being gay is wrong, why are people born this way? Now abortion is a whole different matter. I'm not even religious, I find myself being doubtful and agnostic (again born this way) but when the fetus can be shown fully formed so soon and feeling pain, I may be the most politically left-wing person in America who questions abortion. Even though I guess women should decide this issue and men may not even have the right for a say-so. As I said, Opher, thought-provoking. And Sussy had better get on here because she's the one who said I should read your stuff!! -- Mike

Posted on 01/28/2008 at 4:01:05 AM

 
Very well written article. I have maintained the same stance that a seperation between church and state must be kept in order for us to continue as a Nation.

Posted on 01/28/2008 at 3:01:06 AM

 
Well said - had a big speech going but changed it to the well said LOL

Posted on 01/27/2008 at 5:01:54 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 11 of 11
 
Most Commented On