Find » Opinion/Editorial » Should Cell Phones Be Allowed in Sc...

Should Cell Phones Be Allowed in School?

By Countrymom, published Feb 13, 2008
Published Content: 133  Total Views: 20,230  Favorited By: 13 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.6 of 5
Every year more and more kids get cell phones. Every year the kids are younger and younger when they get their cell phones. Kids as young as 9 and 10 years old now own cell phones. As we ask ourselves why these young kids need cell phones many possibilities come to mind.

Perhaps these kids have both parents working and need a way to stay in touchr en route to and from school. Perhaps some of them take public transportation to and from school or live in a rough neighborhood. A cell phone can be a vital tool in these situations. Perhaps some of the older ones have an after school job that they need to stay in touch with. The list of possibilities is endless.

So what sorts of rules can parents and teachers impose on these students?

Out of politeness for the other students and teachers, turn off your cell phones during class. A cell phone, even if it is on vibrate, can distract other students and teachers.

Utilize voice mail during school hours. If a student is expecting a message from a parent or employer, they can check their voice mails between classes or at lunch.

Do not text during class either. It makes it look like you are cheating, even if you are not. It is also distracting to fellow students and the teachers.

Return calls before or after class or at lunch. Return Texts before or after class or at lunch.

If your friend asks you what was being said during class time or what the answers are, ask them why they need to know when they were there. If they were on the cell phone or texting chances are your friend was not paying attention to what they should have been. Is that really fair to you when you were paying attention?

How can our students learn when they are distracted by their fellow student and a cell phone? How can the student learn when they are so caught up using the cell phone during class?

Takeaways
  • Cell phones in school
  • Cell phones in the classroom
  • Students and cell phones
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
 
At our school, faculty are to confiscate cell phones that are turned on during class and turn them in to administration until the end of the school day. One area school instituted an automatic suspension for such an offense, but that really seems too harsh to me. The texting drives me crazy . . . it's hard to catch, and can definitely be used for cheating.

Posted on 02/24/2008 at 7:02:19 PM

 
That is very true in all ways because then the parent is imediatly imformed on the topic. But in the first place students shouldn't have the cell phones out during class time. But i think it is totally fair to be able to use it during passing periods or during lunch, it is the students time to have fun and do what they please.

Posted on 02/19/2008 at 5:02:57 PM

 
I agree with Kal. My kids do not go to a traditional school as they are homeschoolers, but they do take classes 2 days a week, and they got their cell phones at age 11. While I have no problem with a cell phone getting confiscated for inappropriate use, I would be livid if someone tried to keep my kids phone for several months... either they would also have to pay the bill, or give the phone back to me. I would be glad to pick up the phone though and would apologize to the teacher and take steps to make sure my kid does not break the rules again. While the article is very good, I feel that people presume too much authority over other people's kids.

Posted on 02/14/2008 at 10:02:52 AM

 
Excellent article !

Posted on 02/13/2008 at 7:02:25 PM

 
I can't say as I approve of the teacher keeping the cell phone until the end of the quarter or year, due both to liability issues (should the teacher be held financially responsible if someone breaks into their desk or locker and steals the accumulation of phones?) and the fact that in some cases the cell phone (as you mentioned) is an important and mandatory tool, even if it was misused. Would a teacher have the right to confiscate a student's car until the end of the quarter or year? There are property right issues that come up in these cases, but more importantly there are parental issues the supersede the teacher's right to do keep an item for so long. I think the appropriate action for the teacher to take would be to confiscate the cell phone until the parent can come to retrieve it. If the student needs it right away, it's likely the parent will be more inclined to go out of his/her way to obtain it, which also makes the parent immediately aware of such a problem. Lengthy commen

Posted on 02/13/2008 at 6:02:25 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
Most Commented On