Piano, Digital Piano or Keyboard: Which is Best for a Child's Piano Lessons?

The Pros and Cons for Purchasing a Piano, Digital Piano or Electronic Keyboard for Your Child's Piano Lessons

By Julie Lind, published Mar 06, 2008
Published Content: 47  Total Views: 192,937  Favorited By: 8 CPs
Rating: 4.7 of 5
Now that you've signed your child up for piano lessons, you are faced with a big decision. Should you buy a piano, a digital piano, or an electronic keyboard? As a piano teacher, and owner of a piano, digital piano and an electronic keyboard, I will give you the pros and cons of owning each type of instrument.

When you are making your decision, consider that making music on a quality instrument is one of the best ways to keep your child interested in piano lessons. Why spend so much money on piano lessons only to have your child play on a cheap keyboard?

Before purchasing an instrument, find out from your child's piano teacher if he or she requires a piano. Many piano teachers will refuse to accept students who do not have a real piano. Some teachers will allow students to practice on a smaller keyboard, but only for the first couple of months until you are able to purchase a piano. Most piano teachers allow digital pianos, but agree that your child would have the best chance of success on a real piano. This is especially true if your child hopes to get to advanced level playing.

Pianos have 88 keys, and produce sound by striking steel strings with felt hammers. There are two basic forms of pianos, grand and upright. Pianos range in price from $2,000 to more than $60,000. Pianos are a good investment since they hold their value for years to come.

There are also many quality used pianos available on the market. But be careful, not all pianos are good pianos. Don't be tempted to take the first free piano you find on Craig's List. You should have a piano technician look over any used piano you are considering.

Some music stores will let you rent a piano which is a great option for those who are unable or hesitant to purchase a piano.

People have many reasons for not wanting to purchase a piano including:

Piano, Digital Piano or Keyboard: Which is Best for a Child's Piano Lessons?

Nothing can compare to the touch and sound of a "real" piano

Credit: Julie Lind

Copyright: Julie Lind

Takeaways
  • Some piano teachers require a "real" piano for piano lessons
  • There are many reasons why people feel they cannot purchase a piano
  • Electronic Keyboards with less than 88 keys are not recommended for piano lessons
Did You Know?
The drop-out rate for piano lesson students with electronic keyboards is much higher than the drop-out rate for students who own a piano
Resources
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
 
 
Sorry, that should be 1927, not 1827.

Posted on 06/04/2008 at 4:06:07 PM

 
One option to save money is to buy an older upright piano. These might be a little bit cheaper, but they are very heavy. This is actually a good thing. Most modern pianos have a wooden soundboard, which could crack with a sudden weather change, rendering your piano useless. Older pianos tend to have a cast iron soundboard, which means they're horrible to move, but the soundboard won't break unless you drop it. My parents have an older piano (it's a Hudson's Bay Company piano, meaning it was made in or before 1827) and it has worked very well for many years.

Posted on 06/04/2008 at 4:06:55 PM

 
I am a pianist and piano technician and agree with your comments about keyboard actions, but there are several digital pianos with hammer actions which are as good as or better than those of mediocre pianos, and there are so many bad pianos...

Posted on 03/15/2008 at 7:03:50 AM

 
Phew! Good. I made the correct choice! I started taking piano lessons and showing my boys how to play. Get more for my buck! hee hee!

Posted on 03/07/2008 at 9:03:52 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
 
Most Commented On