Texas Art Teacher Fired for Taking Children to an Art Museum?

Parent Complains that Fifth Grade Student was Exposed to Nudity in Artwork

At what age does it become appropriate for children to see a naked human body as part of a work of art? And, does it matter what form the art is in?
Earlier this week, a veteran Texas art teacher was suspended and told her contract would not be renewed at the end of the school year. She claims it was because of a parent’s complaint regarding artwork a fifth grade child saw while visiting the Dallas Museum of Art.
Officials for the school district claim the teacher was reprimanded by the principal several times since the April museum outing for things like improperly prepared lesson plans, but the teacher said she never had any trouble, or reprimands, until the complaint about the art field trip.
So, back to the original question. At what age is it appropriate for a child to observe statues or paintings that depict the naked human body? And, is it different if the artwork is more absolutely like real like a photograph?
In other cultures, this question can become even more extreme or not an issue at all. Fountains in gardens, frescoes in churches and statues throughout Europe depict everything from cherubs and Roman goddesses in the nude. Granted, these depictions often do not include full-frontal nudity and are not always specifically anatomically correct, but should we be shrouding 10 or 11-year-olds from the reality of the human form?
What I’d really like to know from someone who actually heard the parent’s complaint is, Does this parent allow their child to see supermodels in runway clothing? Does the child watch television? What type of artwork is appropriate for children and when do we introduce them to the concept of the nudity?
Recently, I interviewed a forensics interviewer for a local child advocacy center. She told me that when she goes into junior high schools to educate children about dating, date rape and decision-making about their own sexuality, it is often too late! If it’s too late by the time they hit 13-years-old, when is it appropriate?
I have to believe that this school board is over-reacting, possibly to a parent with a lot of political sway. I know when I was that age one of my classmate’s parents objected to her reading Jack London because of the language involved. Thankfully, my school board simply gave that child an alternative text to read. No doubt, it was a pain for the teacher and the child involved was horribly embarrassed by her father’s stance, but he didn’t manage to remove an experienced educator from her post because of it as has happened in Texas.
Certainly, there is a need to protect children from pornography and graphic sexualization. There is definitely a problem with children, young girls especially, wanting to be teenagers or mini-adults long before they are ready, but if the human form is off limits as artwork, hundreds of years of culture is thrown away.
This school district’s reaction takes the ideal of personal responsibility for rearing children away from the parents and blames a teacher for her doing her job. What a tragedy!


Related information
  • The child involved was in fifth grade.
  • The art teacher had cleared the field trip with school officials.
  • The art eacher has taught in Texas schools for 28 years.
 
Comments 1 - 10 of 10  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

I just think people are too complaint happy in today's society. Grow up! Teach your children about human anatomy and the beauty of the human form. Both of my parents are art school grads and I was taken to many art galleries where nude art was displayed. We are so small minded in the US. Don't you think there are bigger fish to fry?

Posted on 11/09/2006 at 1:11:00 PM

Why is it that in America we cater to the lowest possible denominator. This is ridiculous. Don't go to Europe or any other beach outside of the U.S.. How small minded can people be. Focus on a real issue.Your stupid children who can not speak their own language let alone another. Inless ofcourse it is spanish and that is because they are illegals. This country is in serious trouble. I wonder how many murders this childs parents let him or her watch on television on a daily basis.

Posted on 10/11/2006 at 11:10:00 PM

Before everyone trashes the parent of this child I feel we should really understand the whole story. My child went on this trip and he found nothing wrong with the nude Art. The wrong thing to do is jump to conclusions if in deed you are not personally involved. It wasn't the nude Art that got her fired. Our district has gone to this same Museum for years and will conintue to go. The trip itself was not very well orchestrated which to my understanding the real complaint was that it seemed chaotic and unorganized. It could also be possible that this parent was taken back with the whole experince not just the nudity but the lack of direction for this outing. My understanding having been a parent at his school is that the Art teacher fired was let go due to discipline issues before and after this incident. In defense of the Administrators, I have never seen anything other than fairness and professionalism when dealing with a teacher/parent complaint. It is easy to get on a band

Posted on 10/06/2006 at 3:10:00 PM

I am appalled by the whole situation! I am an art teacher for middle schoolers here in OK. I tell them up front that there may be some nude forms seen in class(not intentionally, but with art history, you are exposed to the nude form)I too would like to know if this child watches tv! Commercials alone are more offensive than any classical or modern art work concerned with the human form, be it nude or clothed.

Posted on 10/06/2006 at 11:10:00 AM

I would like to find out where to support this art teacher to help get their job back last time i checked as a parent "I" have to sing a consent form to let my child go on a field trip it sounds to me like this childs parent is not involved enough in their childs day to day live to know what was or was not at this museum I do not see how this is the teachers fault at the least the parent should be able to help the child process what this is ART in my opinion this is a parent who is not involved in their childs live enough and want's the school to do the work for them!

Posted on 10/05/2006 at 7:10:00 PM

With this thinking -- all encyclopedias with photos of Venus De Milo or Rodin's The Kiss and numerous other examples of ancient art should be banned from school libraries. Maybe National Geographic magazines should also be banned. If the nudity in the museum is so offensive then the Museum should be closed down or only allow adults admittance. I am totally outraged!!! And to boot in california they want to teach which historic characters in US history is gay! Our culture is totally messed up.

Posted on 10/02/2006 at 10:10:00 AM

I grew up in South Africa under the hated apartheid regime. Cennsorship was everywhere. Magazines such a Playboy, were banned, as were movies which the authorities thought were offensive. I can see this kind of closed mind coming to the USA under this tightassed administration.

Posted on 09/30/2006 at 10:09:00 AM

I find it odd that the parent was shocked enough to complain about the fact that his/her child saw some nudity in an art museum.

Posted on 09/30/2006 at 10:09:00 AM

I fear that this is but a sign of more to come...if the current Administration and those who support it are not stopped-censorship may well become the norm..and the paradoxes will continue...it seems the more our society trends toward neo-conservatist ideas, the more extreme the sexualization of youth becomes...

Posted on 09/29/2006 at 8:09:00 PM

Is this what we have come to? Are we regressing to the point where we will soon be seeing "banned" lists? What I think is happening is that society is becoming as hypocritical as our leadership. There is graphic sexualization, but there is a more prudish "over" culture. It is a paradox created by a society that is insecure itself...

Posted on 09/27/2006 at 9:09:00 PM

Comments 1 - 10 of 10