Does Fantasy Baseball Detract from the Real Thing?

A Look into Fantasy Vs. Reality

By wassup471, published Apr 04, 2008
Published Content: 55  Total Views: 6,957  Favorited By: 5 CPs
Rating: 4.6 of 5
I'll admit it: I'm playing too much fantasy baseball this year. Last year, I only played in two leagues, and won them both thanks to strong runs in the playoffs from players who got hot at the right time (a.k.a. I got a bit lucky). So of course, I took that success to mean I knew what I was doing, and promptly joined 5 leagues this year.

I kind of regret it.

See, last season, if it didn't effect the Braves (good stuff) or the Yankees (bad stuff), then I didn't care unless I had a fantasy player involved. With only two teams, and similarities between the two rosters, rarely did I have to root for two players going against one another, especially pitchers vs. hitters.

This kept me very tuned in the goings-on of baseball. Toronto's got some good young talent? Well let me pick up Dustin McGowan. Oh, Adam Dunn had a slow first half, but Haren was maybe a bit too good? Let me see if I can negotiate a trade.

Each enhanced the other. Fantasy baseball kept me more in-tune with all the teams playing on a daily basis, instead of just the Braves. And baseball games occasionally had me checking my rosters, seeing how I was doing.

With 5 teams, I have nobody specific to cheer on (save the Braves, of course). I'm just trying to make each team as competitive as possible, and that's a different challenge to go from managing a team in an 8-team league to one in a 20-team brawl in consecutive minutes. But with so many players to look at, there's no point anymore.

This is where the my parents come into my head, saying "Too much of a good thing IS too much of a good thing." I think for the fantasy enthusiast, playing fantasy baseball in concentrated doses really helps baseball become more applicable to themselves, thus making watching a game more interactive. But going overboard, like I did this year, can have the opposite effect. After checking all of my teams, I have little interest in watching a game, only slightly more if it's my team playing, because I'm already "baseballed out." I've seen probably 6 innings total, and while part of that is my college schedule, the other is avoiding what I've already looked at.

Does Fantasy Baseball Detract from the Real Thing?

Fantasy baseball brings a smile to our faces, but does that take away from the actual baseball experience?

Credit: Me

Copyright: Me

Takeaways
  • Shows both sides of the argument
  • Personal analysis of fantasy baseball's effects
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
 
 
I can honestly say that in late innings, I sometimes rout for an opposing player simply because I want the stats. It's greedy I know, but fantasy baseball is almost as big as the game itself.

Posted on 04/11/2008 at 5:04:08 PM

 
interesting article - i love fantasy football but just can't get into the fantasy baseball!

Posted on 04/04/2008 at 3:04:14 PM

 
What Ryan says. It's one thing to want to succeed with your fantasy picks, but you have to be able to separate the fantasy from reality! I agree with you though, it's a great way to get more familiar with players from teams other than from your own faves.

Posted on 04/04/2008 at 2:04:21 PM

 
You've got to know how to separate your team from your fantasy team. While I want my fantasy team to dominate, I would rather see the Pats or Red Sox win it all.

Posted on 04/04/2008 at 1:04:48 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
 
Most Commented On