After Innocent Rendition, Will David Cook Become the Next American Idol?

By Penny, published Apr 09, 2008
Published Content: 26  Total Views: 27,062  Favorited By: 70 CPs
Rating: 4.7 of 5
Will David Cook become the next American Idol? This is a question burning in the minds of many American Idol fans. For me, the answer is simple...David Cook should be the next American Idol.

This week, American Idol's resident rocker, David Cook, took on the song "Innocent" by the alternative rock band, Our Lady Peace. I've been a strong fan of David's from the beginning of this season, so it's with reluctance that I admit my disappointment with his song choice. Please don't get me wrong. It's an excellent song with inspiring lyrics, which is probably the reason David chose the song. I just don't believe this arrangement of "Innocent" properly showcased David Cook's amazing talent and vocal range.

The weakness in this performance for David Cook was primarily due to the large part of the song being sung in his lower register. In my opinion, his voice is most powerful and compelling when he's belting out the higher notes. Overall, this was not David Cook's best performance but I don't believe it will deter his devoted American Idol fans from continuing to support him. Week after week, David Cook has brought a unique, rock edge to the American Idol stage. He has been a consistently strong performer and commanding stage presence throughout this season of American Idol and deserves to make it into the finale.

What other American Idols have the potential to rival David Cook in the finale? In my opinion, the top three American Idol contestants this year will be David Cook, David Archuleta, and Michael Johns.

First, let's look at young David Archuleta. I agree that he is an extremely talented singer but I find his performances to be kind of boring, at times. If David Archuleta wants to win this competition, he needs to bring more excitement to his performances. If America chooses the next American Idol based on cuteness and sweet personality, then yes, David Archuleta has a huge chance.

Takeaways
  • The top three American Idol contestants will be David Cook, David Archuleta, and Michael Johns.
  • Week after week, David Cook has brought a unique, rock edge to the American Idol stage.
  • David Cook should be the next American Idol.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 41
Next >>
 
Great analysis Penny! OLP is one of my favorite bands too (Cook has a weird penchant for Canuck bands) but I also thought the arrangement could have showcased his voice better.

Posted on 05/14/2008 at 5:05:17 PM

 
another interesting one.

Posted on 05/08/2008 at 10:05:38 AM

 
I love American Idol and think David has a good chance going all the way.

Posted on 05/05/2008 at 9:05:19 PM

 
I know some who watch Idol every chance they get. I'm afraid it just isn't my thing. Maybe I need to have my own island like Michy :-). Regardless, well written.

Posted on 05/05/2008 at 1:05:06 PM

 
(shaking head) Shoot me now, but I just can't get into the American Idol craze like most seem to be doing... ah well... I'll stay over here on my island...LOL

Posted on 05/05/2008 at 12:05:49 PM

 
I missed this week's episodes, have to root for fellow okie Cook though.

Posted on 05/02/2008 at 7:05:12 PM

 
Michael is my favorite

Posted on 04/26/2008 at 3:04:23 PM

 
Now Michael was my favorite but I did vote once for David. Good review

Posted on 04/24/2008 at 8:04:32 AM

 
I don't watch the show. Wanna know why? There are so many well written write ups (like his one) about it that I;d rather read what people have to say about it than actually watch it. If someone writes something stellar about one of the performances then I might check it out on YouTube.

Posted on 04/24/2008 at 1:04:36 AM

 
I don't watch the show. Wanna know why? There are so many well written write ups (like his one) about it that I;d rather read what people have to say about it than actually watch it. If someone writes something stellar about one of the performances then I might check it out on YouTube.

Posted on 04/24/2008 at 1:04:47 AM

 
Good recap :) Sheri

Posted on 04/23/2008 at 11:04:01 PM

 
:)

Posted on 04/18/2008 at 6:04:41 AM

 
Great reporting

Posted on 04/16/2008 at 9:04:29 AM

 
:-)

Posted on 04/15/2008 at 1:04:34 PM

 
Good read, thanks. :o)

Posted on 04/15/2008 at 11:04:35 AM

Type in Your Comments Below
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 41
Next >>
Most Commented On