Fair and Balanced Do Not Apply to Academia

Where the Right Gets it Wrong

By Max Power, published Oct 06, 2006
Published Content: 80  Total Views: 90,580  Favorited By: 9 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.3 of 5
One of the unfortunates of living with someone who watches The O'Reilly Factor is the sometimes you catch a whif of the bile yourself.  Tonight, Bill had as his guest two students from Columbia University - one a charming, well-polished President of the young Republicans, the other a bumbling Allen Colmes clone who is the Editor-in-Chief of the school newspaper.  Around his third comment or question, Bill just threw the matter at hand (the near-riot at a speaking event last night) straight to four winds and went straight to his Agenda (yes, I meant to capitalize that).

Looking right at the left-leaning editor-in-chief, he said, "recently we found that every single Professor at the Columbia School of Journalism was a Democrat.  Don't you think the environment would be a little more friendly if it was more like 50-50?  Shouldn't conservatives have a fair shot at education?"  He then went on to use irresponsible and offensive terms like "liberal jihad" to describe our campuses in a manaical tirade.

The answer to your question, Bill, is no.  Conservatives do not deserve a fair shot at education.  Neitherdo liberals, libertarians, socialists, fascists, anarchists, environmentalists, nor any other political creed.  Want to know why no political sect is entitled to a voice in academia?  Read this, Bill, if you can:

A good college education has nothing to do with the political beliefs of the teachers.  The best colleges in the country do not screen out potential candidates due to political affiliation.  If they did, it would be discrimination.  What gets published in the journals has nothing to do with political affiliation.  The arguments currently going on in most intellectual fields have nothing to do with modern politics.  Papers are not graded with political slants.  College classrooms are not the place to bring up the platforms of political parties and discuss who is better.   They are the place to discuss the issues pertaining to the student's education or training in that specific field or topic.

Fair and Balanced Do Not Apply to Academia

"Okay, that's one semester on Nietzsche, one semester on Falwell. Fair and Balanced!"

Credit: Griszka Niewiadomski

Copyright: Found at ww.sxc.hu, no restrictions.

Takeaways
  • A good education has nothing to do with the politics of its teachers.
  • If you're going to a school that professes to be "Fair and Balanced," drop out immediately.
  • "Fair and Balanced" would mean a socialist could teach macroeconomics. Are you ready for that?
Did You Know?
During the Vietnam War, people with PhDs were the last group to say "bring the troops home."
Comments
Showing Comment 1 of 1
 
 
Yes! Thank you for saying what has needed to be said! I'm tired of pundits assuming that balance just means giving each side 50% of the talking time, without weighing in the quality of evidence, like when an international scientist is forced to sit opposite a lumberjack to debate the long term ecological effect of deforestation. Well said!

Posted on 10/14/2006 at 7:10:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comment 1 of 1
 
Most Commented On