Allegory in Battlestar Galactica: Why New Caprica is Not Iraq

By Mark Whittington, published Oct 18, 2006
Published Content: 521  Total Views: 401,819  Favorited By: 15 CPs
Rating: 3.8 of 5
The modern incarnation of Battlestar Galactica, like its somewhat campier counterpart from the late 1970s, is a dark story of how a human civilization consisting of twelve colonies is all but destroyed by a race of intelligent machines known as the Cylons. The last remains of this civilization are on the run in a motley collection of star ships, protected by a space going battleship/carrier called the Battlestar Galactica, attempting to find refuge on a legendary planet known as “Earth.” They are pursued by Cylon ships, determined to finish off the rest of the human race.

The 1970s version of the series was great fun and certainly had its moments. The 21st Century version has risen to the level of an epic, with its depiction of humanity just on the edge of destruction, if not by the Cylons, then by their deep, human flaws. But along with the flaws has been nobility and honor, a determination to fight on even in the face of certain annihilation.

Season Three of Battlestar Galactica finds the fugitive humans in very dire straits indeed. At the end of Season Two, the humans aboard the fugitive fleet held an election for their President. The statesmanlike President Laura Roslyn, who had been Secretary of Education before the destruction of the Twelve Colonies, was voted out of office in favor of Gaius Baltar, a man who can best be described as a combination of Carl Sagan and Bill Clinton. 

Glib, morally flexible, probably insane, certainly an inadvertent traitor to the human race, Baltar has ascended to office with the promise of ending the long flight across the stars and settling the last of the human race on a newly discovered planet now named New Caprica, after the largest of the destroyed colonies.

This has proven to be a huge mistake, perhaps a fatal one. A year after the arrival of the fleet at New Caprica, the humans are discovered by the Cylons. The Cylons, instead of finishing the job of the total annihilation of humanity, decides instead to occupy and to take control of the colony. The Cylons, who look but do not act as humans, are backed up by an army of Terminator-like Centurions.

Copyright: www.wallpapers.com

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
 
It's been well noted that the occupation of New Caprica has more in common with Vichy France than Iraq. A figurehead president, a strangely Gestapo-like force of traitors, group punishments, and a genocidal indoctrination of the Cylons are a fairly powerful argument in favor of this.

Posted on 01/06/2008 at 3:01:03 AM

 
I think this article exposes the rightist politics of its writer more than anything. New Caprica explores the politics of ocupation; does it matter who is who? And if you don't think suicide bombers in Iraq have to convince themselves of the morality/immorality of their actions, you have fallen into the mistake of de-humanizing your enemies. How sad.

Posted on 07/23/2007 at 7:07:00 AM

 
Yes ,the parallels are indeed too hard to miss...and the fanatic "one god" cylons could represent any fundamentalists. I think that in Galactica they are more representative of the christian right in America than muslime radicals. But the elements apply to both. Whatever your take, you have to admit there has been some very interesting and engaging storytelling.

Posted on 12/08/2006 at 7:12:00 PM

 
I don't think they are trying to be political necessarily, but you have to admit there are definite undertones that could be applied toward the current occupation of Iraq. I think it would be great if all Americans could look at the conflict or "war on terror" from different perspectives. Although the article tries to point out that there are no similarities I would have to say that the Bush administration is pretty well backed by fundamental Christians who believe in one god. I would hope if anything it makes some people think about what the Iraqi's are going through if even for just a minute, they may have some sympathy for the "terrorists". Blah, blah, blah, it really doesn't matter anymore anyway, because I think

Posted on 10/26/2006 at 12:10:00 PM

 
I was initially drawn to 'Galactica' for its Sci Fi pedigree but I have become obsessed with it because of its dramatic elements. While there are many parallels to be drawn from the story line and our current state of world affairs and politics, I dont think they meant as a political statement. Rather, they use current events to enhance the storyline by giving us something to relate to. Many popular dramas like 'Law and Order' have been doing this for years. I like how they take the issue and use their universe to give us a different point of view of these events. Agreeable or not, it makes for great television.

Posted on 10/18/2006 at 11:10:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
Most Commented On