Michael Johns Voted Off on American Idol: Idol Gives Back, but Michael Gets the Boot

In a specially scheduled Thursday elimination, Michael Johns was given the boot on American Idol. Joining him in the bottom two were Carly Smithson and Syesha Mercado. Ryan Seacrest was especially cruel this time around. Seacrest pointed out that last year on Idol Gives Back, no one was eliminated (giving Michael Johns and the American Idol audience false hope). "This year, we're going to say good bye to Michael Johns." Way to twist the knife, Seacrest!

Who should have gone instead of Michael Johns?

Carly Smithson: Known for daring fashion statements and flair for the dramatic, Carly Smithson took on Queen's The Show Must Go On. While her vocals were strong, it wasn't her best performance on American Idol. The performance came across as angry and shouting, not an ideal mood for Inspiration Week. However, as soon as Simon Cowell told Carly she was "in danger" this week, I knew she would be safe. The best way to mobilize a fan base is to convince the fans that their contestant is in danger. Jasmine Trias? Scott Savol?

Syesha Mercado: With her big hair and personality, Syesha Mercado is another polarizing contestant on American Idol. Syesha was panned by Randy and Simon after singing Fantasia's I Believe. While I think she was vocally stronger than Fantasia, Fantasia brought a unique signature style that was missing in Syesha's performance.

Kristy Lee Cook: Kristy may be the Carmen Rasmussen of this season--a pretty, wholesome blonde with a country vibe who overstays her welcome on American Idol. This week Kristy Lee Cook took on Martina McBride's Anyway. It was a decent rendition, but after weeks of lackluster performances on American Idol, I thought her time was up. Yet Simon was right in pointing out that Kristy picked the right song to appeal to her American Idol demographic.

What went wrong with Michael Johns on American Idol?

Performance Order: Michael Johns sang first this week. This is often the kiss of death on American Idol. Audiences usually remember the last performances of the night. The first performers on American Idol tend to get lost in the shuffle.