Supreme Court Gives the OK to Proceed with Executions

News in Brief: Lethal Injection Ruled Not Cruel and Unusual for Humans

Executions in the USA have been "on hold" for the last 7 months while the Supreme court ruled whether lethal injection, the method used to execute prisoners is cruel and unusual, and violates the 8th amendment.

According to The New York Times, yesterday, in a vote of 7-2, the court has decided that executions may resume. Inmates from Kentucky, Ralph Baze, along with Ralph Bowling challenged the Supreme Court in a law
Supreme Court Gives the OK to Proceed with Executions
Date: April 17, 2007
Washington, WA
United States of America
 suit claiming that the three drug cocktail was indeed cruel and unusual. They lost.

Although the court claims it's not cruel and unusual, according to The Texas Gazette most veterinarians are not allowed to use the same method to euthanize an animal. And in Texas, the state called "the busiest killing state," one has to receive a license in order to be a technician to euthanize an animal. It takes up to 2 years of study to receive this license. The executioner and his team are untrained and carry no license to kill. Medical staff are not allowed to assist in executions as it goes against their code of ethics.

Botched executions are common in the nation and many abolitionist claim it is the use of lethal injection. The thought of an inmate being paralyzed by the first drug, unable to move or speak out, while the remaining drugs flow through their veins, is cruel and unusual in some peoples opinions. It's not allowed for animals, so why should it be allowed for humans?

In December of 2006, an inmate in Florida, Angel Diaz was administered lethal injection and it took over a half hour for him to die. According to reports from St. Petersburg Times, a second dose of the drug was given to Diaz, who appeared to be in much pain. This is not the first botched execution in our nation. Many of the offenders have collapsed veins from intensive drug use and makes it difficult to administer the 3 drugs. Ohio botched the execution of Christopher Newton when they could not find a vein, and it took 2 hours to execute him.

Related information
  • Lethal Injection Is not cruel for humans, only animals.
  • Botched execution occur often.
  • States reinstate the death penalty.
 
Comments 1 - 10 of 17 Next >>
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Matt, Bush appointed David Souter to the court. Breyer was appointed by Clinton. Souter was President Bush's "mistake."

Posted on 05/05/2008 at 5:05:15 PM

Thanking everyone for the comments, I really appreciate them

Posted on 04/25/2008 at 8:04:16 AM

Oops. Meant to say Old Bush considered choosing Breyer to be his biggest mistake.

Posted on 04/24/2008 at 11:04:37 AM

Hi Dee. I wanted to fire a brick at my TV set, on CBS's report. They didn't even report which justices voted which way. I suppose Stevens is getting old and stupid. One scary point is that if Old Bush didn't make his "biggest mistake," it would have been 8-1. Naturally, the only woman being the one who knows better.

Posted on 04/24/2008 at 11:04:44 AM

Excellent reporting on this one

Posted on 04/23/2008 at 3:04:52 AM

This is monstrous I have to say that I am not totally against the death penalty, but not for punishment, but in cases like Ted bundy where he escaped and went on another killing rampage, If they can not keep them totally imprisoned then it is a necessity to protect the public, but that is very very unlikely scenario. Otherwise it is monstrous.

Posted on 04/22/2008 at 9:04:47 PM

A overdose of opiates would be painless, but legalities of non-medical personnel handling such drugs would make it impossible. Maybe Dr. Kevorkian could help. I'm opposed to the death penalty generally but in some cases, such as Timothy McVeigh's (he wanted to be executed as soon after his trial as possible) or in cases of war-criminals, it still has validity. What really amazes me is that they put people on suicide watch on death row, robbing the condemned prisoner of even that final act of individual will Some writers have used the term "thanatocracy," (government by death) to describe what this society is coming to. The US ranks number 5 in executions. China is number 1, with an estimated 470 executions, Iran comes in second at 317, Saudi Arabia is third, at 143, Pakistan ranks fourt with 135. The US come in 5th with a mere 42, but that's one hell of a club to belong to, and if things keep going on like this, we will be able to compete with communist dictatorships and Islamic Theoc

Posted on 04/22/2008 at 9:04:10 AM

This was a bad decision... Great article Dee!

Posted on 04/20/2008 at 7:04:32 AM

Not too cruel should have been the correct answer with this verdict!

Posted on 04/19/2008 at 8:04:42 PM

Excellent reporting on a very hotly debated issue.

Posted on 04/19/2008 at 4:04:14 PM

Comments 1 - 10 of 17 Next >>