Contrasting Religions and Cults

By Brett, published Apr 20, 2008
Published Content: 90  Total Views: 14,955  Favorited By: 16 CPs
Rating: 3.9 of 5
As anyone who has even glanced at my CP page will notice, I have been doing a great deal of research into the Church of Scientology. Recently, I started seeing some aspects of my own religious life differently. This is not to say that at any time I thought to myself that what I was going through at the moment was brainwashing or anything else of the sort; it is part of my nature to look at the world through multiple perspectives and it is not uncommon for one of these persectives to be critical of my own beliefs. I always have doubts, but I am never consumed by them.

A couple days ago, I sat down and decided to deal with these natural but no less troublesome thoughts. I asked myself if the evidence of the resurrection of Jesus Christ is in any way dismissable. The answer was no. I asked myself if it is dismissable that the Bible has been consistently proven coreect. The answer was no. I asked myself if the historical evidence of God (Emperor Constantine, Joan d' Arc, etc...) was in any way dismissable. The answer was no. I asked myself if Einstein's belief that the universe must have an intelligent Creator was trustworthy. The answer was yes.

I was now sure that my faith in God had not been shaken, despite the skeptical voice that arose every time I witnessed a form of worship. Later, I went over the methods of brainwashing employed by the Church of $cientology, slowly counting off every aspect of the cult. When I finished I was astonished that so many people can attribute the many qualities of a cult to normal religions. I remembered those individuals who have suggested that a world full of atheists would be world without evil. I recalled also, a line from the Ender's Shadow series in which Grant told Peter Wiggin that the International Fleet had not trusted him until Achilles came along and showed them all what a real tryant looks like. Allow me now to demonstrate what a real threat to humanity and liberty looks like.

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 7 of 7
 
 
I really like your writing - great work - thanks :-)

Posted on 05/10/2008 at 1:05:55 AM

 
A superb analysis Brett. Excellent!

Posted on 04/28/2008 at 8:04:35 PM

 
Excellent comments by JLN. Brett, i'm surprised you aren't bored by jeff's drivel yet. i must admit his last comment isn't as transparent as his usual..but glad to see you got is number. keep up the good work!

Posted on 04/27/2008 at 9:04:50 PM

 
Oh, one last thing: I believe the biggest contrast between religion and cults is that religion encourages its members to remain close to family and friends, especially those of differing beliefs. A cult encourages ISOLATION and seperation from friends, family, or anyone else out of fear that the influence of the cult will be weakened by such contact (as you so brilliantly put forth in your article on Operation: Reconnect). No healthy, legitimate religion would EVER even suggest that it's members cut themselves off from everyone else on Earth (how spookily similar is this to an abusive spouse/parent who cuts the abused off from all other family and friends?)

Posted on 04/21/2008 at 7:04:34 PM

 
Brett, I admire you for admitting that we all have struggles with our faith. You truly are wise beyond your years! Like you said, we ALL have doubts, but we should never let ourselves be consumed by them!

Posted on 04/21/2008 at 7:04:05 PM

 
Jeff, you have just completely sidestepped my entire argument; you found the detail of my essay with a perfect mix of vulnerablility and irrelevance in order to attack my argument without actually attacking it. I'm still going to argue the point though. If the empty tomb is not a historic fact, then why have so many atheists gone to the trouble of coming up with ideas like the swoon theory, the wrong tomb theory, or simply the idea that the disciples are lying. BTW, please stop talking about how "most Christians" or "most theologians" think and feel, you obviously don't have any real knowledge on such things and simply pretending you do is simply not enough for me to believe you.

Posted on 04/21/2008 at 6:04:36 PM

 
That you say the ressurection is in no way dismissable (even most believers of regard this as an act faith, not history) as well as your other absolutes show that indeed you are a victim of some level of the brainwashing you attack Scientology for. If you could say that your beliefs aren't "provable" but you choose to believe them, at least you would have some credibility. The first sign of fundamentalist brainwashing is the statements that their beliefs are the absolute truth. Be in Scientology, Islam, Christianity, or the F.S.M.

Posted on 04/21/2008 at 11:04:44 AM

Type in Your Comments Below
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 7 of 7
 
Most Commented On