Find » Education » What College Entrance Exam Scores D...

What College Entrance Exam Scores Don't Tell Us

A Ph.D. Recipient's Personal Story

By Dr. Jamie Y. Marable, published May 08, 2008
Published Content: 141  Total Views: 55,056  Favorited By: 90 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.8 of 5
It was one of the biggest letdowns I had experienced at that time in my life. As I awaited letters of acceptance from various colleges that I had applied to, there was one that I hoped for more than any other. The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign was my top choice, and although I was open to other possibilities, I wanted to be at that school most of all.

The letter of acceptance finally came, but with conditions. My college entrance exam composite score was less than stellar, and I was deemed not quite ready for regular college classes. The letter stated that I would have to take developmental (better known as remedial) classes before I could advance to the big league.

Having always worked hard and excelled in school, this news was a blow to my self-esteem. Suddenly I began to question my level of ability, the quality of my previous education and my chances for success in the future. I was too ashamed to tell any of my friends what had happened, because I felt like a failure.

My parents made all the difference in the world during that time. My mother pointed out that something as inconclusive as a number on a piece of paper was not an indicator of my worth or my destiny. She, along with my father, encouraged me to look into some of the other schools that had accepted me so that time and money would not be wasted taking classes I did not need. Though greatly disappointed, I settled on a medium-sized university, where I majored in journalism, wrote weekly articles and editorials for my college newspaper and graduated with honors.

A year-and-a-half or so out of college, I received another letter of acceptance from the University of Illinois. Ready to try again, I had aimed even higher this time by applying to graduate school there. I was admitted without a glitch. I also received a graduate assistantship that came with a tuition waiver and free room and board. Soon thereafter, I would earn a fellowship, renewable for several years. And I went on to earn both my Master of Education and Doctor of Philosophy Degree from the same institution that had labeled me a high-risk student several years prior.

What College Entrance Exam Scores Don't Tell Us

Graduation Day

Credit: Shirley A. Daugherty

Copyright: Dr. Jamie Y. Marable

Comments
Comments 1 - 15 of 21
Next >>
 
Thank you for this article. We're in an age of 'testing' students not on their ability but on their test taking skills. Nice work!

Posted on 06/07/2008 at 11:06:06 AM

 
Excellent job with this! Love your perspective. :-)

Posted on 05/23/2008 at 3:05:15 PM

 
Great article, Jamie! There are ways of getting good test scores without actually learning what is necessary to take one to the next step in term of education indeed. Richard Feynman has a good rant about that in his 'Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!' about how the Brazilian students he taught could memorize things in their textbook perfectly without actually knowing how to apply what the books say to real life situations. I'm glad there are folks like you around! :o)

Posted on 05/20/2008 at 5:05:31 PM

 
Very good report, interesting points you have given to establish a serious thing. Interesting article as always.

Posted on 05/18/2008 at 11:05:25 AM

 
D.A. - I am glad that you found this article to be inspiring! A.M. - your story is one that people also need to hear. I have encountered hundreds of students pursuing degrees in math or science-based disciplines who were told (by a teacher, counselor, or some other academic professional) that they should consider a different career or major because they tested poorly in math. As one who went on to become an engineer despite having to take developmental math courses at the start of your college career, you set a wonderful example of all that can be achieved. Genie - thanks for your comments!!!

Posted on 05/10/2008 at 12:05:13 PM

 
Awesome article! Thank you for sharing your experience, I know it will help and inspire others. Personally, I love to learn and absorb the new knowledge. I like thinking about how this new knowledge affects what else I know. In other words I'm a thinker. I do not test well. On essay tests I do wonderfully, but those multiple choice and true and false questions trip me up.

Posted on 05/10/2008 at 12:05:13 PM

 
Great personal story of triumph Dr. Jamie. When I first entered college I was placed in remedial math classes based on my ACT score. In high school, I was a honor student so as you mentioned in your article it was a devastating blow to my ego. It was a humbling experience but I still managed to do fairly well in college. Thanks again for sharing such personal aspects of your journey. We hear so much about success but rarely about the bumpy road in getting there. Peace and Love.

Posted on 05/10/2008 at 11:05:00 AM

 
A great bit of inspiration here!!!

Posted on 05/09/2008 at 5:05:12 PM

 
Gary - thanks for the additional thoughts. You are right - there are many other problems with our educaton system that still need to be ironed out, and it is enough to give one quite a headache. Hope the Tylenol helped! :)

Posted on 05/09/2008 at 11:05:08 AM

 
Love the cynicism Barefoot. LOL. You have made some great points though, in the unique way that only you can make them. Had I entered graduate school expecting to enjoy a big monetary payoff in the end, I probably would not have finished. I knew going into it that the rewards would not necessarily be tangible ones, though modest salary differentials have been a part of the equation for me. And I didn't spend anywhere near $100,000 on my education. My children have benefitted because I, along with other family members, serve as an example that one should always think and dream big - and aim high. And we do still occasionally eat Raman Noodles :)

Posted on 05/09/2008 at 11:05:04 AM

 
The American Education System has always been a burr under my saddle for more reasons than I can count on my fingers and toes; you can even extrapolate your story to include dealing with unfair teachers. I have tried to help my three sons by telling them that life isn't fair; there will not be "Cosmic Justice" while on this earth so use these experiences such as yours (and with unfair teachers) to learn how to figure out how to deal with unfair situations. What amazes me is how quick we are to want to "add" tasks to a person who has demonstrated the willingness to work. At any rate, very well done per usual and you obviously overcame the needless roadblocks set before you. As I said, the educational system gives me a pain therefore I'll be popping a couple of Extra Strength Tylenol and lying down with a cool rag over my eyes now. Best, Gary

Posted on 05/09/2008 at 9:05:13 AM

 
What is the monetary gain for my degree? I need to know if reaching for the stars will pay off in diamonds. My BA is keeping me comfortable, but will the extra $100,000 I spend to get my MA or PhD. pay off before I die? How will my children benefit? How many Raman Noddles do I have to eat before I can rest?

Posted on 05/09/2008 at 12:05:40 AM

 
To everyone who has commented thus far, thank you so much for the wonderful feedback and for sharing your own thoughts and experiences as they relate to this topic. This is a personal story that I have shared with a number of students who've experienced doubt on the way to achieving their educational goals, and I am glad that AC has provided me with a larger audience of people to convey this important message to. I hope that my story will be an inspiration to someone out there who is struggling to succeed against the odds.

Posted on 05/08/2008 at 7:05:27 PM

 
this is so true !!....so glad that you wrote this...some students get so "down" when they make really bad scores on these test !

Posted on 05/08/2008 at 7:05:14 PM

 
This will be an inspiring article for many.....................success comes as a result of staying focused and having the confidence in one's own ability.................

Posted on 05/08/2008 at 6:05:52 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 15 of 21
Next >>
Advertisment