And the Winner of American Idol is . . .
A Comparison and Analysis of Both David Archuleta and David Cook
By Stephanie Modkins, published May 16, 2008
Published Content: 486 Total Views: 416,873 Favorited By: 10 CPs
Singing Talent
Admittedly, both men can sing. What's the difference? David Archuleta has the ability to draw in a crowd based on vocals alone while David Cook has to use a few tools. It's a truth that the American Idol judges fail to bring out when they are busy praising him. If David Cook had sung the majority of his re-spun songs as usual, he would not have been so popular. On the other hand, David Archuleta has such a magnetic voice; he could sing a cappella and still wow the listeners.
Stage Presence
In regards to each David's ability to perform in front of a crowd, the prize goes to David Cook. His rock n' roll style is likened to many professionals today and adds to his ability to impress a crowd. David Cook is extremely shy and this, at times, erodes away at his performance. It is an aspect about his stage performance that he will have to work on in the future. So, he needs to make eye contact, dance and flaunt his "stuff" with confidence.
Physical Appeal
Who is sexier? David Archuleta? David Cook? It really depends on whom you ask. However, if you look at the trend that dominates the music industry, little Archuleta has the edge. His baby face will attract a wide range of fans where as David Cook's unique features might do just the opposite.
Record-selling Potential
Both men have huge record selling potential. Why? Each has a genre of music that they can enter today and dominate in. For David Cook, he could start making rock music today and be a success. On the other hand, David Archuleta could be a pop sensation with R&B crossover appeal. So after the show ends and a winner declared, both men will have bright futures in the music industry.
And the Winner of American Idol is . . .
Location:
USA
You may also like...
- American Idol Predictions
- The Davids Stay on Top on "American Idol"
- David Cook First, David Archuleta Second: American Idol Top Five
- American Idol: David Archuleta is the Next American Idol
- Syesha Mercado Will Go Home; American Idol Producers Paved Way to David Cook, David Archuleta
- American Idol Countdown: With Only Three Left, Competition Down to the Wire
- American Idol: the Scotsman's Predictions
- A Look at the 2008 American Idol Live Tour
- American Idol Top Four: the War of the Davids
- Just Hand Over the American Idol Title to David Cook, Already!
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Most Commented On


