The Rare Voice of Women in Music History: Females Singing Tenor and Bass Lines

Where Italian Castrati Regularly Replaced Women, the Italian Ospedale Were Doing Just the Opposite in the Male-dominant Baroque Era

By Hayley Reep, published Dec 11, 2006
Published Content: 2  Total Views: 1,809  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Rating: 3.6 of 5
Any history is burdened by the politics of its transcriber, and music history is not exempt from this bias. A chronology of Western music history consists of European males influenced by other European males, starting from the Medieval Age and continuing through the beginning of the twentieth century. This homogenous history is largely due to the fact that other voices of the time, specifically women, were silenced by politics and religion. The notable absence of women within music history motivates scholars today to represent the feminine influence as best they can. Due to the modern more favorable political and religious climates, women in early music are now receiving their chance for owed representation. One area where women musicians left their mark was in the Baroque-era ospedale of Italy. There women were reversing the gender discriminatory practice of males playing female roles in operas and in religious music.

It was not until the nineteenth century before women were regularly found performing in opera houses or in church music. From the early monasteries and convents in the Middle Ages, women and men were separated in a religious context. Women possessed no role in the mass setting, and this naturally extended to an exclusion from all church music as well. Politically they were inferior to their male counterparts, generally translating to women not owning property, voting, or holding leadership positions of any consequence within society. Although musicologists today argue that there must have existed a number of women composers throughout music history, there is little documentation of their work with the exception of women such as Hildegard von Bingen in the eleventh century and Barbara Strozzi in the early seventeenth century.

Takeaways
  • Women are now becoming a focus in music history.
  • Men replaced women in music performance until the 1800s.
  • In one discovered exception, women replaced men in choirs at the Italian ospedale.
Did You Know?
Women didn't perform regularly in opera or in churches until the 1800s.
Resources
  • For a more in-depth look at the gender question in the ospedale, see Michael Talbot's  "Tenors and Basses at the Venetian 'Ospedali'" inActa Musicologica, Vol. 66, Fasc. 2. ; Available online from JSTOR journal database (subscription required).
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 3 of 3
 
 
They compelled themselves to be brilliant and interesting, which is why their work continues to be rebroadcast constantly. They did not trollop on stage dressed in something that came out of a strip joint's dumpster. They did not bump and grind their anatomy to a loud thumping drumbeat, then half-sing-half-scream their insipid lyrics to a drooling audience. Their work remains true and listenable and watchable to this day simply because they used their brains and bodies properly.

Posted on 09/19/2007 at 7:09:00 AM

 
Funny how the word "soprano," in its MASCULINE form, indicating a MALE singer, should be attached to a woman, who would be called a "soprani" singing in the same vocal range. It's like tacking the adjective "actor" to someone like Jodie Foster or Charlize Theron. If there is any doubt about the raw sexual nature of women performing on stage, then Madonna, Britney Spears, the Pussycat Dolls, Kylie Minogue, Shakira, and Christina Aguilera should quash any doubts about that. Unfortunately, these females have also quashed the work of good women who have worked arduously to set a standard for the best in female performances. Persons like the late Beverly Sills, Dame Margot Fonteyn, Maria Callas, Isola Jones, and Julia Migenes come to mind, as well as Dame Vera Lynn and even Lucille Ball as a comedienne. They expected themselves, and were expected by others, to maintain standards of beauty and grace on and off stage. They remained properly dressed. Sex was a taboo to them. They c

Posted on 09/19/2007 at 7:09:00 AM

 
What an interesting and very readable piece! Thank you--I enjoyed it very much.

Posted on 02/28/2007 at 3:02:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 3 of 3
 
Most Commented On