Is a Whites-Only Scholarship Wrong?

Should African Americana Be Angered by a Whites-Only Scholarship?

Recent news of a whites-only scholarship announced by Joe Mroszczyk, president of the College Republicans at Boston University has many African Americans in an uproar. As an African American myself, my feelings are mixed. The fact however that Mr. Mroszczyk
 is surprised by the negative response is laughable. My opinion is that the $250.00 scholarship offer was done for nothing more than to make a point. My question is was his point really made.

To receive this scholarship worth enough money to buy books for one semester, applicants must score a 3.2 or higher GPA, write two essays, and be at least ¼ Caucasian. The group's effort to explain their bias is in an attached explanation that states, "We believe that racial preferences in all their forms are perhaps the worst form of bigotry confronting America today". Therefore, by excluding racial groups from the scholarship, they are therefore boycotting scholarships that exclude racial groups. How poetic.

I find it difficult to be bothered by this scholarship/ publicity stunt. After all, I was the recipient of several African American-only scholarships as a young coed. I did not have a problem with the local African American Elks club paying for my books. Why should I have a problem with the College Republicans at Boston University paying for the books of someone who is at least ¼ Caucasian? That would be hypocritical of me wouldn't it?

This is not the first time a scholarship of this nature has been offered. Just two years ago, the College Republicans at Roger Williams University offered the same scholarship. This attempt to stir up conversation about racial preferences has been dismissed as "a poor way to talk about affirmative action" by the president of the schools Latino fraternity, David Coreas. (I have to wonder if this Latino fraternity admits whites.)

Related information
 
Comments 1 - 10 of 30 Next >>
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

You are correct. If I creates a WET white entertainment television station it would create the same contraversy. I think we are way beyond this now and I am as poor as other people white or black so why do we put race in it. Because racism exists on both sides.

Posted on 05/19/2009 at 12:05:44 PM

Of course racism exists. It is alive and well around the whole world. The problem comes in when one group is racist for having whites only anything while other groups are politically correct and doing the right thing for furthering the advancement of the poor and downtrodden (but only if you are the minority of the day). There should be one standard across the board. If it's private,offer whatever you want to whomever you want but don't knock me if I offer the same thing. Whites won't apply for this scholarship because they would be labeled as racists just for applying while black only, etc, scholarships are offered everywhere and that is seen as a good thing. One standard - that's what we should be striving for. Not the double standard that's everywhere today.

Posted on 03/17/2009 at 10:03:53 AM

From what I have learned, minority scholarships have been offered in effort to provide minorities the opportunity to better their lives through college opportunities. I believe that these scholarships originated at a time when minorities were unable for afford the opportunity to attend college because of the historically oppression of their family. Minority scholarships are now offered, usually due to a minority or group of minorities who has the opportunity to extend this to memebers of his or her race in hopes that it will continue to better that group of people. However, I feel confident in saying that we are now in a day and age to where people of all races have equal opportunities as well as challenges to face when it comes to being able to pay for a college education and achieve success in a career. I feel there is nothing wrong with offering a "whites-only scholarship" as long as there is still "African American-only" or "Hispanic-only" scholarships. Why not offer opportunities

Posted on 01/18/2008 at 10:01:14 AM

How is it fair for minorities to be able to get scholarships, just for them...Like all of these Hispanics only, African-Americans only...What about white people? I support a Whites Only Scholarship, and I think we need to see more of it.

Posted on 01/08/2008 at 12:01:00 PM

Does the first amendment protect our rights of free speech and assembly or does it not? It's common law that giving things, particularly money, is a way of expression and subsequently speech... What right does our government, or we as a society have to dissallow this scholarship given for a particular group or any other scholarship for whatever group intended? The people who privately fund these should be able give them out to whoever they want without all this controversy. If the scholarships are publically funded, they shouldn't be discriminatory in any way, excluding the obvious merit/need factors. That's a problem i think even for state universities. I dont think i'm really the best one to talk, having recieved the top academic scholarship offered for my school, but many people haven't been given a scholarship because they were not in the pool of minority applicants. The only bad part of this is that this is for a public university...

Posted on 01/11/2007 at 9:01:00 PM

All I'm asking is that you challenge your assumptions, the way you probably want people to challenge theirs when reading your article. By the way, I also found your article well written, although I disagree with scholarships that aren't based on need or grades. I would have said more about it previously but I ran out of time and space. It just seems that a writer who really cares about equality in college would take five minutes to do a search on "coed" and "sexist". One female professor has an esp. good article. Again, thanks for adding to AC with this article.

Posted on 12/01/2006 at 6:12:00 PM

Coed means college women. I know what it means... thanks

Posted on 11/30/2006 at 8:11:00 PM

This is a little besides the point, but does the author know that referring to herself as a "young coed" is using a sexist term? "Coed" is short for co-educational, which was used to indicate a female student when colleges first started admitting women. It was used to distinguish women because "college student" meant male by default. To convey that's any reason to differentiate between a male or female student - that gender matters at all - is sexist.

Posted on 11/30/2006 at 7:11:00 PM

lillie, what I said is that they either don't need it or don't want it... and 3 weeks is more than a little time when book money is sitting on the table.

Posted on 11/30/2006 at 3:11:00 PM

I enjoyed the article until I read the last page. The author implies that white people don't need scholarships, but I have heard of scholarships that are never applied for at all and this one has only a little while. And I agree with many of the people on here about the fact that 1/4 white doesn't exactly rule out many people. I also have a 4.0 and am not eligible for most scholarships that are given by colleges because I'm not a minority.

Posted on 11/30/2006 at 1:11:00 PM

Comments 1 - 10 of 30 Next >>